You are what you eat

Do you believe that old saying, “you are what you eat”?

It must be true … here is a little peek at my family …

The Peanut Butter Man

My hubby ate so many Nutter Butter Cookies … he turned into one … hahaha!

I was actually very kind in the making of this Nutter Butter Man … I didn’t include the white hair that is growing in his goatee … he’s got a little Colonel Sanders thing going on.  Please don’t tell him that I shared that little bit of info 😉

The Nutter Butter thing runs in the family …

My 3 Nutter Butter Sons

I have three sons … Son #1 has light brown hair and usually a full beard … Son #2 has red hair and is clean-shaven … Son #3 would have blonde hair if he let it grow and has a goatee.

These Nutter Butter people have been in my mind for some time.  Sunday is Father’s Day and it’s baseball season … perfect timing!

Please forgive me … I didn’t even think about making girls until I was typing this post.  I have a tendency to think in boy terms, but  I’m sure that it would very simple to adapt.

Once again this is a super simple project and here is what you will need …

Nutter Butter Baseball supplies

  • Nutter Butter Cookies
  • Mini Nilla Wafers
  • Candy Eyes
  • Candy Melts or Candy Coating in your choice of colors (melted)
  • A serrated knife
  • A wax paper or parchment lined tray

Nutter Butter Boys Instructions

  1. Cut Mini Nilla Wafers in half to create a baseball hat bill.  Use a toothpick (or whatever works for you) and melted candy to create hair on a Nutter Butter.
  2. Place “hat bill” on hair and let dry.
  3. Dip the top of the Nutter Butter and top of the mini Nilla Wafer to create a baseball hat.  Let dry or chill for a few minutes
  4. Use a toothpick and melted candy to attach candy eyes and make a smile.
  5. Add a little facial hair and you are done!

Maybe the Nutter Butter baseball players could use these bats and balls

Baseball - pretzel bats & marshmallow balls

♦  This may be shared with these great parties ♦ 


10 thoughts on “You are what you eat

  1. let’s hear it for the (pb) boys! woohoo! i think your family nutter butters should party with my mustache nutter butters. wowza imagine the fun! the colonel can bring the chicken! heeheehaha
    oh and btw, i think it’s pretty awesome we are connected in some way! 🙂


  2. They could double as construction workers or baseball players. The 3D hats are really good. Yah – do some girls for us. You know we need your guidance.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s